Sentenced to Be a Hero Ep 1 Review
Happy New Year, everyone! And what a good year it is looking to be for the world of anime! We are going to see the return of many popular anime that we here at the D&A Anime Blog are all looking forward to seeing. However, I think that the first big hit of the year is an entirely new show. A show that’s animated by some of the people that made the first season of Mushoku Tensei: Jobless Reincarnation a legend of animation. As a fan of that Isekai series and agreeing that the animation from the first season was near god-tier, that fact alone was enough to get me interested in this. However, now I’m going to want to stay for the story, because Sentenced to be a Hero has the potential to be one of the best anime of the year.
I feel so good about being right.
Sentenced to be a Hero Inverts the Praise that Comes with the Word
The hero. A four-letter word that has done more to inspire feelings of hope, courage, and inspiration than any other in existence. It’s a concept that appears in every culture that’s ever existed, and one that comes with respect. That is not the case for the premise behind Sentenced to be a Hero, though. Before we even get to see the animation (which is god-tier), we get a text block explaining what a hero is in this story. In this story, being a hero is a punishment for the worst criminals. They are sentenced to fight on the frontlines in the never-ending war against Demons until they drop dead. They’re not even granted the peace of death, as they’re revived and forced to continue fighting, as unending cannon fodder, for eternity.
Now, this isn’t the first time I’ve seen a story where someone called a hero is treated terribly by those they’re having to save. It sure as heck isn’t the first time I’ve seen death being irrelevant to a story. And of course, we have video games, where players are expected to die and then have to start back from their last save. For all we know, science and technology could give people alive today the ability to tell death to piss off for as long as we want.
But dying is still dying, and while Goku and the others are able to shrug it off with zero signs of mental trauma, that’s not the case for everyone. It’s still going to hurt, and even someone with the strongest mentality they could possibly have is going to start cracking if they experience that over and over. And as we are introduced to the world of the show and its main cast, Sentenced to be a Hero demonstrates this in all its nightmare-fueled glory.
Xylo Has a Bone to Pick With those in Power
We are introduced to our main character, Xylo, in the middle of a battle against the Demons as one of his fellow Heroes steals something from their “allies.” The other Hero, Dotta, almost bites it and asks to die so he can be revived. However, as Xylo tells him, dying and then having your soul ripped out of the afterlife has consequences. It will erode away a person’s soul, causing them to lose memories of who they were until there’s almost nothing left. He even makes it a point to say that if happens enough times, a Hero will be like a living zombie!
Now, we may never know for certain if there is an afterlife, or if we reincarnate, or cease to exist. But compared to what Xylo is describing, death seems better. Regardless of whatever crimes a person may commit, I don’t think anyone deserves to suffer a fate like that. Whoever came up with that system must be some morally bankrupt sadist!
What makes it even worse, though, is that the crime that Xylo was sentenced to be a hero for wasn’t even his fault. As the end of the episode reveals, he was put in an impossible situation and left to die.
Goddesses are Little Girls.
In the world of the show, there are beings called goddesses, little girls who were created to help humanity fight the Demons by bestowing contracts on their chosen champions. Xylo made a pact with one such goddess after his unit was sent into a battle as cannon fodder with no reinforcements. That goddess used up so much of her power that she hit her breaking point and started to turn into a demon herself, forcing Xylo to put her out of her misery. If that wasn’t traumatizing enough, the country’s leaders placed all the blame on him, saying he acted without orders, that he was never ordered to fight, and that he killed her in cold blood. And they were saying all of this at his trial right to his face.
Basically, take what Naofumi went through and somehow crank that up to eleven. That’s how bad this is. And so, Xylo did what any sane, rational, understandably pissed-off person would do: he vowed revenge. He vowed that he would find the people who set him up and make them wish they had given him the death penalty when they had the chance!
I’ve seen it happen plenty of times in fiction, but it never fails to grind my gears than to see a good person get screwed over by those in power. It takes a rare kind of person to endure that level of getting screwed over to not want to seek revenge, and while I applaud those who can move on, I understand why Xylo acts so bitter throughout this first episode. He’s saving so many lives and looking badass while doing so, but his so-called allies spit on him anyway when they don’t know a thing. Even worse, when he ends up meeting another goddess, Teoritta, his ptsd is triggered. The girl only wants to help him, but he claims he hates goddesses and tries to drive her away. In the end, though, circumstances force the two to work together in order to win, meaning they’re now stuck with each other. And also Dotta, who stole the casket holding Teoritta in the first place.
Remember how Peak Season One of Mushoku Tensei Was? This is it on Steroids
There was a lot to unpack for this first episode, not the least bit because it was an hour long. But beyond the story, which sounds super interesting, the main draw of the episode was the animation. This show is directed by the people who helped to make the first season of Mushoku Tensei one of the most beautiful anime in living memory. From the bread scene to the fight between Dead End and Orsted to Eris fighting those knights in her solo ova, that first season was gorgeous beyond belief. And this episode was pretty much each of those moments extended into an hour.
To start with, there’s the color palette. Most of this episode is set at night, and they reflect this using a lot of dark colors. It’s doubly appropriate considering how this is a dark fantasy series. The animation is smooth as butter, especially during the fighting scenes. As for the fighting scenes, take the best ones from Mushoku Tensei and yourself what made them look so good. Now apply that to every fight in this episode. It’s a visual feast.
I’ve got a number of anime that I want to cover for the Winter 2026 season, and after seeing this episode, I can say that Sentenced to be a Hero is going to be one of them.
D&A Anime Blog 